Home | Poptropica | Island Smackdown Round Two – Great Pumpkin vs. Counterfeit

Island Smackdown Round Two – Great Pumpkin vs. Counterfeit

Round Two of the Poptropica Island Smackdown comes to its final battle. After this, we’re on to the Final Four. In this last confrontation for the round we have Great Pumpkin Island squaring off against Counterfeit Island.

Great Pumpkin is of course very new, released this past Halloween. It is set inside the world of Charlie Brown and the Peanuts gang and you play out the island just like the script of the television special. You’ll go trick or treating, attend a Halloween Party and even help Snoopy the World War I flying ace fight the Red Baron and sneak behind enemy lines. Great Pumpkin Island is a short adventure, but it’s packed with several fun puzzles and mini-games.

Counterfeit Island arrived a little over a year ago and became one of the most popular islands in Poptropica. It was a bit of a surprise–everyone was expecting Reality TV Island, but that showed up later. Counterfeit did not disappoint. In this island, you have to stop a powerful and world-famous art thief from stealing Edvard Munch’s The Scream, which is on display at the island’s art museum. There are twists and turns to the plot and a very difficult final battle with the arch-villain, Black Widow. And of course, Counterfeit Island features Balloon Boy, and who could ask for anything more?

Both were fun to play. But only one can win in this head-to-head battle to see who will advance to the Final Four. Which will it be? Counterfeit or Great Pumpkin? You decide…

Which Island is Better?

  • Counterfeit (70%, 879 Votes)
  • Great Pumpkin (31%, 388 Votes)

Total Voters: 1,263

Loading ... Loading ...

About Fierce Moon

Fierce Moon is the chief blogger here at PoptropicaSecrets.com and loves to play Poptropica along with a bunch of other online games.

74 comments

  1. 1st to comment!!! go counterfeit!

  2. second to comment!! XD if u ppl dont vote for counterfiet, then u dont have a life!!!

  3. go counterfeit YEAH!!!! oh and 4th to coment

  4. counterfeit is so much better, because there’s sooo much more action, plus in great pumpkin there’s no boss battle. counterfeit is probably my favorite poptropica island!

  5. Polly the awesome girl

    Nice costume Indiana Jones! It is called the loading sign, peoples!
    Go Great Pumpkin! And by the way, Brave Tiger, u don’t have a life

  6. Polly the awesome girl

    and by the way, also there’s a boss battle in Great Pumpkin ! The Red Baron vs Snoopy! I like snoopy much better! Cuter!

  7. Please click my name and tell me what you think about my costume!

  8. psophia– where did you get the shirt?

  9. Princess Middle East

    Go Counterfeit island!
    🙂

  10. Princess Middle East

    Nice costume psophia!

  11. Nice costume psophia. Indiana Jones, I hope you don’t mind, but I put on that Indiana Jones costume.

  12. Nice costume psophia! Have you tried pairing with a black belt? That might look nice.

  13. Sandy, the Ten year old girl

    Cute outfit, psophia!

  14. Counterfeit is so much better! You get to fight the Black Widow! Great Pumpkin really is counterfeit,you know… I’m still a chinese! (I told you before!)

  15. thx cuddly walker! i dont mind at all!

  16. When I said great pumpkin was counterfeit I meant It was fake! Counterfeit still rules!

  17. go GREAT PUMPKIN

  18. COUNTERFEIT IS THE MOST BORING ISLAND

  19. BRAVE TIGER YOU DONT HAVE A LIFE

  20. everybody is all WRONG, WRONG, and WRONG. They BOTH rock.

  21. ur right dizzy claw. i think they should be called…

    COUNTERGREAT ISLAND!

  22. i totally agree. anybody who doesn’t like both islands DOESN’T HAVE A LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  23. BY THE WAY INDIANA JONES I SAW A “YOU” ISLAND ON POPTROPICA WIKI(INDIANA JONES ISLAND OR SOMETHING).

  24. by the way indiana jones, ayian, and polly the awesome girl you guys don’t have a life

  25. white horse, the link didnt work! 🙁 what website should i go to to see the Indiana Jones island thingy?

  26. If people don’t have a life then why are they typing.

  27. counterfeit + great pumpkin both rock, i just like counterfeit a bit better, and the red barron fight in great pumpkin was beast!

  28. Counterfeit rocks but Snoppy is more awesome than me!
    (How do you get the avatar studio link?)

  29. Nice costume, psophia! Love it ! But where did you get the shirt?

  30. I love creating costumes! Especially COUNTERFEIT ISLAND outfits! Pls click on my name to see my latest creation!

  31. Check out my rockin’ costume!!!!! 🙂

  32. this was pretty hard, because I voted for both of them in round one. But counterfeit island is my all time favourite, so i voted for it. But now I feel like voting for great pumpkin as well.

  33. Attention everyone! I am giving out aFREE poptropica account!

    1) U: dmagicsinger P: sings

    Please tell me if you are willing to take it!

  34. Island Smackdown Round Two – Great Pumpkin vs. Counterfeit
    by PoptropicaSecrets on January 8, 2011

    Round Two of the Poptropica Island Smackdown comes to its final battle. After this, we’re on to the Final Four. In this last confrontation for the round we have Great Pumpkin Island squaring off against Counterfeit Island.

    Great Pumpkin is of course very new, released this past Halloween. It is set inside the world of Charlie Brown and the Peanuts gang and you play out the island just like the script of the television special. You’ll go trick or treating, attend a Halloween Party and even help Snoopy the World War I flying ace fight the Red Baron and sneak behind enemy lines. Great Pumpkin Island is a short adventure, but it’s packed with several fun puzzles and mini-games.

    Counterfeit Island arrived a little over a year ago and became one of the most popular islands in Poptropica. It was a bit of a surprise–everyone was expecting Reality TV Island, but that showed up later. Counterfeit did not disappoint. In this island, you have to stop a powerful and world-famous art thief from stealing Edvard Munch’s The Scream, which is on display at the island’s art museum. There are twists and turns to the plot and a very difficult final battle with the arch-villain, Black Widow. And of course, Counterfeit Island features Balloon Boy, and who could ask for anything more?

    Both were fun to play. But only one can win in this head-to-head battle to see who will advance to the Final Four. Which will it be? Counterfeit or Great Pumpkin? You decide…

    Which Island is Better?

    Counterfeit (70%, 537 Votes)
    Great Pumpkin (30%, 232 Votes)
    Total Voters: 769

    Loading …
    Related posts:

    Island Smackdown – Haunted House vs. Great Pumpkin
    End of Round One for Poptropica Island Smackdown
    Island Smackdown Round Two – Mythology vs. Steamworks
    Island Smackdown – Astro-Knights vs. Counterfeit
    Island Smackdown Round Two – Shark Tooth vs. Time Tangled
    Tagged as: counterfeit island, great pumpkin island, island smackdown, poptropica, poptropica island smackdown

    { 31 comments… read them below or add one }

    Indiana Jones January 8, 2011 at 7:49 am
    1st to comment!!! go counterfeit!

    Brave Tiger January 8, 2011 at 8:12 am
    second to comment!! XD if u ppl dont vote for counterfiet, then u dont have a life!!!

    Super Tornado (Trystan) January 8, 2011 at 8:22 am
    3d to commet! Go Counteirfeit!

    invisible axe January 8, 2011 at 8:29 am
    go counterfeit YEAH!!!! oh and 4th to coment

    Indiana Jones January 8, 2011 at 8:49 am
    counter pones!

    Indiana Jones January 8, 2011 at 8:52 am
    counterfeit is so much better, because there’s sooo much more action, plus in great pumpkin there’s no boss battle. counterfeit is probably my favorite poptropica island!

    Indiana Jones January 8, 2011 at 8:52 am
    click my name!

    Polly the awesome girl January 8, 2011 at 9:12 am
    Nice costume Indiana Jones! It is called the loading sign, peoples!
    Go Great Pumpkin! And by the way, Brave Tiger, u don’t have a life

    Polly the awesome girl January 8, 2011 at 9:13 am
    and by the way, also there’s a boss battle in Great Pumpkin ! The Red Baron vs Snoopy! I like snoopy much better! Cuter!

    psophia January 8, 2011 at 9:37 am
    Please click my name and tell me what you think about my costume!

    Princess Middle East January 8, 2011 at 10:57 am
    Go Counterfeit island!

    Princess Middle East January 8, 2011 at 10:57 am
    Nice costume psophia!

    Cuddly Walker January 8, 2011 at 11:11 am
    Nice costume psophia. Indiana Jones, I hope you don’t mind, but I put on that Indiana Jones costume.

    ShinyPear January 8, 2011 at 12:07 pm
    Nice costume psophia! Have you tried pairing with a black belt? That might look nice.

    Sandy, the Ten year old girl January 8, 2011 at 12:10 pm
    Cute outfit, psophia!

    Indiana Jones January 8, 2011 at 1:16 pm
    thx cuddly walker! i dont mind at all!

    Ayian January 8, 2011 at 1:56 pm
    go GREAT PUMPKIN

    Ayian January 8, 2011 at 2:01 pm
    COUNTERFEIT IS THE MOST BORING ISLAND

    Ayian January 8, 2011 at 2:03 pm
    BRAVE TIGER YOU DONT HAVE A LIFE

    Dizzy Claw January 8, 2011 at 2:53 pm
    everybody is all WRONG, WRONG, and WRONG. They BOTH rock.

    White Sword January 8, 2011 at 2:57 pm
    ur right dizzy claw. i think they should be called…

    COUNTERGREAT ISLAND!

    Lucky Ice January 8, 2011 at 2:58 pm
    i totally agree. anybody who doesn’t like both islands DOESN’T HAVE A LIFE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    White Sword January 8, 2011 at 3:00 pm
    BY THE WAY INDIANA JONES I SAW A “YOU” ISLAND ON POPTROPICA WIKI(INDIANA JONES ISLAND OR SOMETHING).

    White Sword January 8, 2011 at 3:00 pm
    http://www.poptropica.com/wikia

    White Sword January 8, 2011 at 3:01 pm
    by the way indiana jones, ayian, and polly the awesome girl you guys don’t have a life

    Rough Horse January 8, 2011 at 3:19 pm
    you guys are so wierd.

    Indiana Jones January 8, 2011 at 3:39 pm
    white horse, the link didnt work! what website should i go to to see the Indiana Jones island thingy?

    Cuddly Walker January 8, 2011 at 5:39 pm
    If people don’t have a life then why are they typing.

    Indiana Jones January 8, 2011 at 6:20 pm
    counterfeit + great pumpkin both rock, i just like counterfeit a bit better, and the red barron fight in great pumpkin was beast!

    Cheerful Beetle January 8, 2011 at 8:39 pm
    Nice costume, psophia! Love it ! But where did you get the shirt?

    Red Heart January 8, 2011 at 11:17 pm
    this was pretty hard, because I voted for both of them in round one. But counterfeit island is my all time favourite, so i voted for it. But now I feel like voting for great pumpkin as well.

    Leave a Comment

    Name *

    E-mail *

    Website

  35. who knows why theres no adverts

  36. Who has the whole Percy Jackson costume on Poptropica? If you give it to me I will give you a super rare costume.

  37. Polly the awesome girl

    White Sword January 8, 2011 at 3:01 pm
    by the way indiana jones, ayian, and polly the awesome girl you guys don’t have a life! Yeah, right! U don’t have a life. I love both islands! That’s just rude, White Sword! I’m reporting u!

  38. Polly the awesome girl

    aafafasfa
    fa

  39. GO COUNTERFEIT! new pic! 🙂

  40. here we go….i hope

  41. counterfeit is so much more fun!!!:)

  42. how do you make an avatar?

  43. I’m one for proper names, the name, Indiana Jones, was WHITE SWORD, not WHITE HORSE. I’d hate it if someone called me something I’m not.

    And just so everybody reads this 😡 :
    PLEASE STOP WITH THE “YOU DON’T HAVE A LIFE” POSTS. THIS IS AN OPINION TOPIC. IT EVEN SAYS ON THE VERY LAST SENTENCE: “Which will it be? Counterfeit or Great Pumpkin? You decide… ” YEAH, WE DECIDE, MAYBE NOT ALL ALIKE, BUT WE DECIDE. SO WHAT IF SOME PEOPLE LIKE COUNTERFEIT, BUT NOT GREAT PUMPKIN??? AND SO WHAT IF PEOPLE LIKE GREAT PUMPKIN, BUT NOT COUNTERFEIT. AND THE SAME WITH PEOPLE WHO LIKE BOTH, AND PEOPLE WHO LIKE NEITHER!!!
    People are one of a kind. Everybody is different. That includes in opinion too. It’s stupid criticizing someone’s opinion. They have a reason for their choice, and so do YOU. Anyone has a right to state their opinion, but no one should have a right to criticize it. SO PLEASE STOP THE “YOU DON’T HAVE A LIFE” THING, CUZ YOU’RE JUST LOSING YOUR LIFE ENERGY POSTING THIS NONSENSE!!!

    Yeahhh, I’m not trying to be rude, or anything, but it was getting on my nerves. Everyone’s opinion matters. It’s not like, “Because it’s THIS person voting, I’ll just not count their vote.” Everybody’s voice has a right on this topic. Please stop arguing. 😥
    Thanks :mrgreen: !!!

  44. Hey Tough Ring, can you tell me how to do the picture thing??? I’m puzzled on it!! Thanks if possible! 🙂

  45. Maybe they’re buzy? I’m not sure why tiny tornado. It’ll help pass the time until the island comes out for everyone…

  46. I think they’ll do an “Alpha and Omega” ad soon… they may be working on it right now… It’s a hunch though…

  47. Awww man!!! They extended the arrival date of Cryptids Island for everybody!!! 😥
    Instead of the 17th, it’s now the 18th!!! 😥

  48. Hey silver moon, nice outfit. Though I think you’d look better if you smiled. 🙂
    And I have no idea what your talking about. Unless it’s the pictures. I want to know how to too!

  49. OMG people how about we all just talk about Poptropica for once.

  50. Sandy, the Ten year old girl

    Hey, guys! What do you think of my new costume? (Don’t tell my not-a-friend-not-an-enemy that I used her account. But she did write all of her passwords and accounts on the back of my notebook with a pen.) http://www.poptropica.com/avatarstudio/avatar.html?a=bZFBkejBiYTJGMGFIa3lNekF5

  51. ay

    BRAVE TIGER AND WHITE SWORD

    YOU GUYS ARE STUPID

  52. if you dont vote for great pumpkin you dont have a life

  53. Counterfeit. A no-brainer.

  54. Hey click on my name and comment

  55. GO COUNTERFEIT ISLAND!!!!!!!!

  56. Cuddly Walker look. Cost: 75 credits or for free (optional).
    Get the Goth Boy’s Bang on Reality TV island.
    Get Gamer dude’s hair OR put on Hades’ crown and then take it off.
    Find freckles on a Random Poptropican.
    Go to 24 carrot and customize the dude with the 8 shirt’s smile.
    Get Hades’ shirt.
    Find a Random Poptropican with black shorts.
    TA-DA! You are Cuddly Walker!

  57. ayian, what did I JUST SAY?!?!?!?!

  58. stupid d dragonZ

  59. thanks sandy i got a membership

  60. Hey check out my costume!Pretty please!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:cry:!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:mrgreen::):-)

  61. i love poptropica!! plz dont leave any mean comments! 🙂 btw if u c me on poptropica, my name is greygrape…. i no, kind of a stupid name

  62. WILD WEST coming in ferbyary i am a member

  63. Haii pplz! Plz plz plz check out my new avatar!!! I made my hair red! lol

  64. now it red like in real life O.o

  65. can you guys ansewer this question how do you go to early islands please ansewr plz plz plz plz thanks

  66. Jeff Kinney created poptropica, so why didn’t he think of putting his diary of a wimpy kid series in an island earlyier??????????????????????????????