Home | Poptropica | Island Smackdown – 24 Carrot vs. Time Tangled

Island Smackdown – 24 Carrot vs. Time Tangled

OK, Poptropica fans. We’re on to match two of the Poptropica Island Smackdown. In the first battle, Shark Tooth Island put a serious chomp on Early Poptropica, and will advance to the next round. This time, 24 Carrot Island takes on Time Tangled Island. Read a little bit about both islands below and then vote on which is your favorite. The winner after 1,000 votes will advance to the next round!

24 Carrot

Battling Dr. Hare in 24 Carrot Island

Confronting the villain Dr. Hare in Poptropica 24 Carrot Island

In 24 Carrot Island, we met the first true villain in Poptropica, the evil Dr. Hare. When the quest begins, something strange is happening to the island. People have gone missing, and the islands precious carrots have been disappearing. In this quest, you uncover a sinister plot by the mad Dr. Hare and put a stop to his nefarious plans! Dr. Hare was such a popular villain that Poptropica released a follow-up mini-quest to this island called, Dr. Hare’s Secret Lab.

Time Tangled

Leo's Workshop in Time Tangled Island

Inside Leo's workshop in Poptropica Time Tangled Island

In Time Tangled Island, you must travel through different eras in time using a special time travel machine that has malfunctioned. Your quest is to retrieve missing artifacts and return them to their correct eras in time. And then finally, you adventure into the future where you uncover some surprises. In this fun adventure, you can explore the different epochs in any order you like. It’s also a fantastic island for using the costumizer, because you’ll find costumes and outfits from throughout history. There’s even a special hidden item on the island: the legendary Viking Suit!

Let’s Vote

So which of these two islands do you like best? Which one should advance to the next round in the Poptropica Island Smackdown? Vote for your favorite below and check back in a few days to vote on the next set of contenders!

Which Island is Better?

  • Time Tangled (69%, 1,104 Votes)
  • 24 Carrot (31%, 500 Votes)

Total Voters: 1,592

Loading ... Loading ...

About Fierce Moon

Fierce Moon is the chief blogger here at PoptropicaSecrets.com and loves to play Poptropica along with a bunch of other online games.

177 comments

  1. i like time tangled because u go back in time. i like 24 carrot because you save a city. i like both

  2. Only 6 votes for 24 Carrot so far!

  3. TIME TANGLED BABY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*plays guitar really loud*

  4. *sings like rocker dude* ROCKING OUT WERE HANGING OUT THATS WHAT I LIKE TO DO, IM IN THE BAND LETS WIN THIS BAND WEASELS ROCKIN IN OUR LIVES CAN WE STAY HOME IN OUR VIBES!?!? WEASELS ROCK YOU CAN WE SAY WHY WEASELS ROCK YOU THE STAGE IS GOING CRAZZY!!!!!!!!!! WEASELS ROCK YOU CAN YOU STAY FROM OUR BAND YOW!! *switches back to normal voice* I know what your thinking Im wierd. Cuddly Walker was playing like I’m In The Band.

  5. i typed this on my ipad!!!!

  6. You get to see historic people on time tangled island!

  7. cool. thanksgiving dinner was GREAT.

  8. GO TIME TANGLED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  9. on club penguin, im trying to get my water helmet.

  10. GO TIME TANGLED!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *wears time tangled shirt*

  11. U people are messed up. 24 Carrot all the way!

  12. Quick, YOU are messed up. 24 carrot is much better.

  13. go time tangled *starts playing a random song*

  14. To Popular Jumper:
    I thought u lik both islands.

    Anyways;
    GO TIME TANGLED!!! U ROCK!!!

  15. Hey guys. Be on here for a little while. I’ve been with my family in Texas since the 15th.
    And……………………………………………..
    TIME TANGLED IS WAY BETTER THAN THAT JACKED UP 24 CARROT ISLAND!
    Thank you.

  16. actually i like time tangled better.

  17. Hey Popular Jumper.

  18. Hey Smart Paw. Im gonna play Club Penguin.

  19. K. cool.

  20. Bonjour. Qui ici se lit Harry Potter?

  21. its cool bieng a ninja. 🙂

  22. Hey Veela.

  23. whoa! there are 347 people on this site!

  24. Bonjour Smart Paw! What are you doing?

  25. 363!
    Oh and I’m proclaiming how many people are on this site.

  26. 366! Leap year!

  27. 365 days!

  28. Back to 366!

  29. Isn’t that kind of boring?

  30. Yeah.
    But. I’m bored. no one is here. It is Black Friday. Shopping.
    I stayed back here and ate pie for breakfast.

  31. 😆
    You ate pie for breakfast.
    😆
    Are you all alone?

  32. No. But almost everyone is asleep.

  33. Cool.
    how was your thanksgiving?

  34. Good.
    380!

  35. Hello Smart Paw.

  36. Hey Cuddly Walker.

  37. Bonjour Cuddly Walker.

  38. Veela. Are you French?

  39. No. But I’m pretending to be. like in Harry potter and the Goblet of Fire. Fleur.

  40. Oh cool.

  41. How was your Thanksgiving Cuddly walker?

  42. 401 people on this site.

  43. Gotta go.
    See ya.

  44. [bold] Time Tangled!! Yea!! *Starts playing C.S.I. Miami theme song really loud*

  45. [b] Go T.T. (time tangled) OH YEA!

  46. Um.. guys, how do you make pictures on the default?

  47. Hi Blue. Go to gravatar.com for image for commenting.

  48. i like 24 carrot

  49. Smart paw otherwise known as Nicholas yep in fact he’s probably all the mean people on here

  50. Go TT! also we’ve been seeing a lot of rookies/newbies/not regulars/new chatters.

  51. Smart Paw said “I am HALF of the people on poptropica secrets. GUESS!!” to me.

  52. Blue Raptor, You comment in bold like this. How to comment in BOLD
    June 26, 2008

    It’s pretty nifty how the default WordPress admin settings allow you to see the top incoming search terms. The top bold lentil terms are currently:

    banana sushi, homemade bottle opener, mccain stencil, holes, personalized styrofoam cups, use of parenthesis, oboe, numonic definition, frogs, john mccain stencil, self.response.out.write, gustave doré, chuck close, unlucky numbers, and so on.

    Which is like whoa. How about that banana sushi post. But then further down the list I see lots of queries for “how to write bold comments” and “how to comment in bold letters” and such and because the blog is titled ‘bold lentil’ people click here.

    Fine.

    Let’s do something useful this time. Assuming the comment window you are typing into supports HTML then to comment in bold you will need to do the following:

    1. start your comment, when you get the word you want in bold stop

    2. type the begin bold tag:

    3. then type your words

    4. the type the end bold tag:

    5. finish your comment.

    So for example if you wanted to comment on this post: “Wow this is such a useful post.” and say you wanted to emphasize the word useful with some bold then you would type: “Wow this is such a useful post.” Which should look like this after it’s posted: “Wow this is such a useful post.” If doesn’t you can always move on to ranting about the sub-par blogging software.

    Hope I helped!!

  53. Popular jumper I saw him say that to you.

  54. wait, let me try it.
    is this working?
    and lemme try the italics…
    hmm…

  55. i know. im on club penguin. Nessabc ur cool.

  56. 24 CARROT ISLAND RULES!!!!! U GET TO PLAY A VIDEO GAME!!!!!!! THAT’S AWESOME!!!!!

  57. ur welcome. club penguin can get boring

  58. Hi!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  59. Yeah CP is boring Poptropica is funner

  60. Wait how do you do italics crossed out and underlined?

  61. OK,
    for italics u put the begining lik this:
    next type whut u want 2 say
    then yo put the ending:

    crossed out is harder
    u have 2 put the 1st like this:
    type what u want 2 say
    then put

  62. Club Penguin Is BORING & FUN

  63. LOL… Hi everyone. I used to play Club Penguin but it became too “fun”. 😀

  64. lets c if that works :HI:

  65. nope i messed up 😀

  66. This is Tough Boa . i prefer Raheat98

  67. I love to type in bold. 😀

  68. hey everybody have u herd of graystar love it.

  69. hey u guys what goes on! hwo loves big time rush! i do and i get 2 go 2 there concret next week
    its gonna be supper cooollllllllllllllllllllllllllll!i loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
    BTR

  70. OK I HADIT how ever said that im the creator of this blog im not i dont no
    who isgosh

  71. love time tangled i really like the people with the sun piece i think they were the myans!!??!!??

  72. i loved24 and time but 24 kindve agervated me

  73. Is this what people are saying, Popular?

  74. well, Cuddly Walker said that.

  75. … ok……. weird.. 😛

  76. myghtythunder you remind me of my sister. She loves BTR.

  77. GO TIME TANGELD WHOO HOOO

  78. 100th comment!!! Yeah!!!

  79. Yeah sure. Blame the Teddy bear that can walk.

  80. No one likes u because u r ugly. u grow warts on ur butt

  81. shut up before i kick ur zit face off the face of the world. *mimicks* No one likes u because your and ugly. *Giggles like a 3 year old* Go Away, Go!! *farts into whistle for 100 hours*
    I was right about you. YOU ARE A GAY JERK!!

  82. The pigs pass out when they see u and smell u

  83. leave me alone. When the ugliest ppl come they say “WOW WHAT A LAME LOSER CUDDLY BOY IS!!! SHE IS SO UGLY WERE GONNA DIE!!!!!!” *ugly ppl die*

  84. and when girls see you, *they die and theyre souls r gone forever* THATS HOW UGLY U R!!!!!!!!!!
    16 and STILL playing poptropica

  85. And Nessabc and I don’t NEED YOU!!!!!!!!!!! Nessabc and I are awesomer than you.

  86. *mocks* HI!!!!!!!!!!!! I’M CUDDLY WALKER!!! I’M JUST GONNA BE MEAN TO RANDOM PPL. MARRY ME, POPULAR JUMPER AND NESSABC!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MARRY ME, I SAY!!!!!!! IM IN LOVE WITH MY SISTER

  87. :0 and just cuz ur jealous doesn’t mean you have to RUIN it for OTHER people.

  88. When your mom first saw u, she killed u from uglieness.

  89. PPL don’t like bullies like you and Rachael Sue Adams.

  90. Your new name is BARBIE!!!!!!!!!!!! 😀

  91. hi ppl how do you defaet astro nights

  92. *mocks*HI!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I’m Un-Popular Jumper and i am a jumpin jelly bean!
    Wow, I just LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE Poptropica and making fun of cuddly because it makes me look cooler! I am very fat and I LOOOOOOOOOOVE TO type in BOLD like this!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Cuddly u r so Jealous of me and Nessabc!!!!!!!!!!! MARRY MEH CUDDLY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  93. *continues mocking*Anyway, I just have the prettiest wart that I like to polish!!!!!!!!!!!!! MEH THINKS BARBIE AND CW IS A PILE OF POOP!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE saying that Cuddly wants to Marry me and Nessabc because me and her go to the bathroom together!!!!!!! CUDDLY QUIT BEING MEAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *runs home and cries like a 3-year old*

  94. popular jumper, you are already a f******* bully from what i saw.

  95. *continues continuing mocking* WOW!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE typing in BOLD! BOLD! BOLD! OOOOOOOOOOOOOOO Cuddly u r soooooooooooooooooooooo jealous of me and nessabc!!!!!!!!!!!!*plays guitar* YES, I KNOWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW! YOU R THINKING I”M WEIRD!!!!!!!!!*giggles like three year old* *put’s TURD in Nessabc’s hair* WOOOOOOOOOW CUDDLY U R SOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO JEALOUS BECAUSE I JUST DID THAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Grigory are u a girl or a boy? I’M SO CURIOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  96. *THROWS ROCK AT LOSER (CUDDLY WALKER OR BOY WITH A GIRLS NAME)*’
    *MOCKS* IM SO GAY I KISS BOYS *SLOBBER KISSING 10,101010101010101010 BOYS*
    YOU HAVE WARTS ON YOUR ASS, UNPOPULAR!!!!!!!!!! *FLAILS LIKE AN IDIOT* I WANT MOMMY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    AM I COOL? NO!! SKITTLES IS COOLER THAN ME!!!!!!!!! *KID THROWS ROCK AT CUDDLY* OW!! WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
    😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥
    😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥
    😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥
    😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥 😥
    WHERES MOMMY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! IM A GIRL!!! I AM A BOY WHO SOUNDS LIKE A GIRL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  97. No. Actually, Cuddly IS a girl.

  98. Yah, he’s so stupid!

  99. *STILL MOCKS*
    I AM WORTHLESS, COME ON GIRLS THROW ME AWAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! MWAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAYAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAGHAHHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHHAHAAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
    *LAUGH CONTINUES FOR 1,000 YEARS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!*

  100. Ummmmmmmmmm, u ok?

  101. WE HATE CUDDLEY WALKER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    RATINGS MOST HATED
    CW: 1ST PLACE SINCE 5000000000000 BC
    SP: 2ND PLACE SINCE 2010

  102. hi. cuddly walker mocked me so i did my revenge

  103. Well, he isn’t all bad. To be honest with u, it looks like U started it. No offense.

  104. U made him feel really bad.

  105. he said “*mimicking*I’m SO PROUD OF NESSABC! Nessabc, will u marry me?” thats stupid

  106. Well, true, but is that something to get all worked up over?

  107. he keeps fighting until ur power is gone

  108. I like Grigory. Hes awesome. and Grigory is right. he is a f********* b***** bully. Did he bully you, Skittles?

  109. i dont like grigory. *takes cupcake and presents away* im giving these presents to SOMEONE who deserves them. Cuddly Walker did start this.

  110. Wow. I realize how stupid you all are. I’m not wasting my time reading the argument.

  111. 1. Not Smart Paw.
    2. smart Paw is a jerk
    3. Although i am
    Ashas Fierce
    Wolfgang
    And other people but I’m not smart Paw
    although I know his account

  112. Skittles. Your like my sister. She always sticks up for me.
    And Cuddly Walker is a jerk.
    i never liked him.
    *And I’m stupid for actually reading this argument. (Which is kind of lame by the way.)*
    Popular Jumper used to be an annoying *hum*. And she still is.
    BUT I’m not in the mood for being mean.
    I’ll do that when I feel like it.

  113. Oh and am I really that bad?
    I’m a jerk.
    But I’m not that bad.
    I’m just naturally mean.
    I can’t help it.

  114. *hits smart paws arm* nicholas, tell smart paw to be nice, oh yeah you ARE smart paw. Just Saying

  115. and so am i and im nice unlike Teddy Crawler

  116. Prove it!
    And Smart Paw shut up for five minutes or OR I’LL CHOP YOUR HEAD OFF!
    T
    hank you.

  117. Hi Popular Jumper.
    And fine nicholas.
    *mutters* Freaks.

  118. actually, your telling yourself that. good job.

  119. Prove it to me Popular Jumper. Prove to me that I’m Smart Paw.

  120. I’m back.
    I can prove that your Smart Paw!

  121. 🙄
    Hm. I can’t believe that your back.
    5 minutes are fast.

  122. Okay. Prove it Smart Paw.

  123. okay.
    Okay.
    hm.
    I forgot what I was about to say.
    Anyway I won’t be on here long.
    Like 6 minutes before I get the heck out of here.

  124. 376 people on here!

  125. 386! And 150 comments!

  126. 387! New page!

  127. Leaving early.
    Bye.

  128. Sorry. I was eating turkey.
    smart Paw!
    Bye.

  129. am i alone?
    You know what?
    That is all cool.

  130. you said you were HALF the people on poptropica secrets.

  131. Soo. That doesn’t mean I’m Smart Paw. La la la da de. Da da da do. Do doo la le.

  132. a face without freckles
    Is like a sky without the stars
    Why waste a second
    Not loving who you are
    Those little imperfections
    Make you beautiful
    Wonderful
    Magical
    They show your personality
    Inside your heart
    Reflecting who you are
    Who you are (Who you are)

  133. I really like the challenge of Time tangled over 24 carrot.

  134. Timetangleddefinitelyrocksover24carrot.

  135. *loved time tangled forever!*

  136. TT is SOOOOOOOOOO better than ST.

  137. time tangled…

  138. 24 CARROT VERY BOURING

  139. 24 carrot time tangled is hard and BORING
    i LOVE the rabbot destruction part

  140. carrot island is boring but i love the rabbot part . <3

  141. time tangled island is sooooo better then an island replacing another island like 24 carrot island

  142. time tangled island is the best except can someone tell me where leos missing thing is

  143. Time tangled, time tangled. And prettyice14, it’s where the statue of liberty is being built. Agh, hard to explain. But it’s on the building on the very left side. There’s this guy standing right next to it, and you should click on him.

  144. Sorry, but I like 24 Carrot better!

  145. i went for time tangled to O.M.G

  146. why does everyone hate 24 carrot island?! (because that’s my vote!)

  147. ppl dat lik time tangeled r lam 24 carrot rokz it haz a bad gi in it duuu

  148. i am going for time tangled

  149. Island 24carrot is not easy .Oh my ! You can help me . Huh ? Please