Home | Poptropica | Poptropica Island Smackdown – Time Tangled vs. Spy

Poptropica Island Smackdown – Time Tangled vs. Spy

Sorry for the long delay in getting the Poptropica Island Smackdown voting going! But now it’s here and we’re ready to rock. We’re now in the Final Four for voting. Only four islands remain:

  • Time Tangled Island
  • Spy Island
  • Counterfeit Island
  • Mythology Island

In the first match-up in the Final Four round, we have Spy Island taking on Time Tangled Island. Both survived two rounds of voting to get here. Time Tangled beat 24 Carrot and then Shark Tooth. Spy Island snuck past Super Power and then Nabooti.

But which one is better? And which deserves to move on to the championship round? Only you can decide! Vote below for your favorite of these two rounds and we’ll see you in the championship!

Which Island is Better?

  • Spy Island (65%, 1,152 Votes)
  • Time Tangled Island (35%, 630 Votes)

Total Voters: 1,782

Loading ... Loading ...

About Fierce Moon

Fierce Moon is the chief blogger here at PoptropicaSecrets.com and loves to play Poptropica along with a bunch of other online games.

113 comments

  1. Sandy, the Mad Dragon

    I have to say Spy. It’s awesome!

  2. Sandy, the Mad Dragon

    YAY! I was first!

  3. 23 votes? That’s not very much…go Time Tangled!

  4. SPY ISLAND, ALL THE WAY! (38th vote) >:D

  5. Spy is WAY better! In Time Tangled all you do is find the items and return them to the right time period, no real challenges.

  6. GO SPY ISLAND!!!!! U ROCK 😀 :mr.green: and im 97th vote although i wanted to be 98th… oh well…

  7. oops 😳 i did that wrong :mrgreen:

  8. now its 101

  9. comment 9

  10. comment 10. yay i made half of comments so far..

  11. TIME TANGLED! all the way! Here is why time tangled island reins supreme: It is a fun, creative, action packed, quest filled with surprises, challenges, and there was a dude there that looked like Indiana Jones! Spy, on the other hand, despite a few sorta cool gadget things, was kind of dull, and their wasn’t much of a story (everyones going to lose their hair! WHO CARES! what a STUPID plot). But with Time Tangled, It actually felt urgent, and important, I mean, who wants the whole future screwed up? And, once you beat it, you get to visit your futuristic house with the cool monorail and air transports. My favorite part about Time Tangled was meeting all the historical figures, (I know that sounds nerdy, but i’m really in to history, and found this island to be very educating, as well as an awesome adventure) like DA Vinci, Tomas Edison, the Oracle of Delphi, and Louis and Clark, just to name a couple. As well as being a fabulous adventure and odyssey, I enjoyed the exotic tone of this island, as you traveled from a remote Viking settlement, to a dangerous Aztec pyramid, to Louis and Clark’s camp. As I’ve said before, Spy totally lacks that aspect, noting that it is set in just one, boring, grey, dull, lump ‘o building. So those are the reasons that a cast my vote to Time Tangled, the first island that I ever completed, one of the most loved, in my opinion the most creative and fun, this island will always stay with me as my favorite and dearest Poptropica island.

  12. it was hard to decide between time tangled and spy. theyre both good.

  13. where are you supose to go whith the mottorecycle and where is the haunted house i just cant find it its making me mad

  14. Sandy, the Mad Dragon

    Here is my very lame story:

    There was once a little girl named Sandy. She has sanity problems. One day, she got went on Poptropica. She created an account named hpboy22 (AN: I’m aware that it’s a boy’s account). And then she watched a movie.

    Sandy lived very happily until one day when she went to fifth grade! She was constantly yelled at and had homework every single day. Until she went on http://poptropicasecrets.com/. Then she lived happily ever as a fashion designer, writer, technician, scientist, and artist. And famous.

    True story, except the fashion designer, writer, technician, scientist, and artist. And famous. part.

  15. HOW COULD U PPL CHOOSE SPY ISLAND?! TIME TANGLED IS AWESOME SO WHOEVA VOTED FOR SPY HAS NO LIFE! D: DX

  16. i love spy, reality tv, and great pumpkin island

  17. Didn;t we already go over that having no life problem? ❓

  18. spy was kind of hard but super fun! thats where my vote went 😀

  19. NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

  20. IF U DONT VOTE FOR TIME TANGLED YOU DONT HAVE A LIFE

  21. WHO IS BETTER

    Time Tangled 100% 486 Votes
    Spy 0% 1 Vote

  22. I am totally undecided on which island I like more.

  23. And the linked website you will go to is the avatar of magic moon from now on, till I’ve finished defeating all the island’s quests. Click on my name please! 🙂

  24. PLS VOTE FOR TIME TANGLED

  25. time tangled will never win at this rate..

  26. the new island coming out is wild west trust me jeff kinney basicly told us

  27. Whatever happens, I will always support Counterfeit. I voted Time Tangled this time, though Spy was really, really, really fun.If Cryptids Island was in the Island smackdown, I don’t know which I would support more…..

  28. SPY ISLAND! so much cool gadgets, and time tangled is just giving stuff back.

  29. I choose Spy island because the bow thing it’s so awesome!!

  30. The following smackdown players from Time Tangled Island:
    The 453 CT Transit driver
    The 468 CT Transit driver
    The 330 CT Transit driver
    The 492 CT Transit driver
    The 484 CT Transit driver
    The 338 CT Transit driver
    The 9613 CT Transit driver
    The 464 CT Transit driver
    The 356 CT Transit driver
    and
    The 337 CT Transit driver
    Spy:
    The 467 CT Transit driver
    The 333 CT Transit driver
    The 476 CT Transit driver
    The 9617 CT Transit driver
    The 348 CT Transit driver
    The 463 CT Transit driver
    The 358 CT Transit driver
    The 461 CT Transit driver
    The 9638 CT Transit driver
    and
    The 361 CT Transit driver

  31. go spy!!

  32. Brave Tiger & Aiyan: By posting that, you proved you have no life! 😮

  33. Indiana Jones: After reading your comment i am staring to wonder whether i should have voted for Time Tangled… oh well i already voted for other island….

  34. Everyone has a life, just ones that aren’t worth it.

    (4 the insulters, the only people on this site who have a serious problem)

    Just a reminder…

    WHICHEVER WINS, IT IS A MAJORITY VOTE, NOT A SINGLE VOTE. IF AN ISLAND YOU DISLIKE, WINS, DOES THAT MEAN IT’LL HAVE TO BE YOUR NEW FAVORITE?
    OF COURSE NOT.
    PEOPLE AREN’T GONNA CHANGE THEIR MINDS JUST BECAUSE YOU SAID SO, OR BECAUSE YOU INSULTED THEM, SAYING THEY HAVE NO LIFE. IT’S THOSE KINDS OF PEOPLE WHO HAVE WORTHLESS LIVES, TRYING TO INSULT PEOPLE.

    Come on’ guys, The purpose of this is to post opinions, not insults.
    You’re right Speedy Singer, we did go over this. 🙂
    Brave Tiger and Ayian aren’t ready to accept that another island could possibly win. 🙁
    So they decide to insult the other island voters.

    Personally, I’d rather have no life than deal with people like you. 😡
    I’m voting for Spy.
    Not only is it an awesome island, but I’m not going to vote for the same island that insulter’s vote for.

  35. 944th voter!!! Kewl!!! 😀 It’s fun to vote!

  36. … it’s a shame though, I was actually thinking about voting for Time Tangled.
    Loved that island…

    But I’m final on my decision.
    It feels good to stick with my decision rather than follow others sayings.

  37. HEEYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!! 🙂 😀 😛 😉

  38. i like time tangled but i’m too lazy too vote

  39. Hi silver moon, what’s up? 🙂

  40. it’s official! Wild West island is the next poptropica island! there is a new island sneak peak now!

  41. YAAYYYY!!! AWESOME!

  42. Sandy, the Mad Dragon

    Anybody there?

  43. Coolio, just won the first prize!

    If you click the refresh button, while running out of time, it should ask you to refresh the entire content, or something like that, and say yes, so then you can replay the game. 😉

  44. Me! Hi Sandy.

    Hey, did you ever come up with your character names? I want to know if I was any help…

  45. Sandy, the Mad Dragon

    I did. And you were a BIG help.

  46. all of you who choose Spy choose that because you didn’t bother to replay Time Tangled again and compare to Spy. I liked Time Tangled

  47. gooooo!!!!!!!!! spy il regret this but who ever votes for time tangled has no life

  48. Cool! I’m so happy now!

    But I have to do the mile-run tomorrow in Gym… 🙁
    I’ve never done it before, but I heard it’s worse than pacers… 😥
    I mean, RUNNING A MILE?!?!? I’m lucky I was able to do 30 pacers!

  49. Sandy, the Mad Dragon

    EP: I feel sorry for you. I can only run for five seconds before I get extremely tired. And I’m not exaggerating.

  50. I wonder why people are afraid of me.

  51. I’m not, Sandy. You’re weird, just like me 😀 Im scared of the dark, Ms. Pehrson, my Daddy, bees, and Super Joker.

  52. hey sandy! your name’s Sandy, the Mad dragon now! cool name! i will, just like u Red heart, will always support Counterfeit island! i TOTALLY voted for Counterfeit. i clicked it about a million times and then realized you can only vote once, and for all.

  53. White Sword: Thanks! You have a cool name too!

  54. Oh, so everyone’s posting here, I was lonely for a minute there…

    You guys are still on, right?

  55. It’s ok Sandy. Although we’re timed, I heard girls have 14 mins to run the mile, and by talking to some kids who already had it, it seems like I can make it… at least I hope so…

  56. Yeah! I was hoping I wasn’t talking to myself! 😀

  57. I wonder what’s scarier, a green ghost or a mad dragon?

  58. I suppose the only reason that I think the talk about running the mile is silly is because I can run a mile in 8 minuets. But I guess that is because I’m in 7th grade 😀

  59. 8 minutes? Wow! I run it in about 9 to 10 minutes.

  60. check out my outfit, “cute, goth, and pink”
    `comment please :mrgreen:

  61. HELLO ❓
    😥 :opps:
    i’m alone!!!!!!!!!!!!

  62. wwwwaaaaiiiiitttttt……
    😥 😳

  63. I GOT IT!!!!!!!!!! 🙂 🙂 😛 😀 :0

  64. OMG

    I’M SO PATHETIC 😉

  65. HELLO!!!!!!!
    hello!!!!!!
    -A DAY WILL COME WHEN YOU WILL BE AS AWESOME AS ME!!!! :mrgreen:
    (don’t worry 😉 )

  66. Hi Sandy didn’t see your comment!

  67. seya peps
    [ i know, finally]
    :mrgreen:
    (Comment on my outfit)
    😉

  68. OMG SNEAK PREVIEW FOR WILD WEST ISLAND!!!!!!!!!
    OPENS FOR MEBERS IN FEB.
    😥 i’m not a member 😥 😳

  69. It’s okay, I’m not one either

  70. Hey, cttransit467! We will have a practice on the final four-round two! Then, we will go to the Walmart Parking Lot-Bus Stop to have a competition! The first season on boys is:
    Padres
    vs.
    Seastars
    The first season on girls is:
    Sea Rays
    vs.
    Thunderbirds
    The girls is at 6p.m.
    The boys is at 7p.m.

  71. Yay!!!! i voted 4 spy!

  72. Hey Ya’ll! How you doin’? 🙂

  73. Hi is anyone on?? I have a room code!!

  74. SUPAH???? ❓ ❓ ❓ ❓ ❓ WOAH!!!!!! ❗ ❗ ❗ ❗ ❗

  75. What happens after you get an avatar studio? BTW, you look good, speedy singer! Are you a member? I’m half a member, half not. 我很喜欢 Poptropica! ( I love poptropica!)

  76. Spy is a good island and mythology WILL get my vote. A lot of other peoples votes too, unless they want to be blown to smithereens!!!!! Huh??? Sorry everybody. I must go calm the fight between Ares and Athena. *sigh*

  77. SMGSMG27, ur password doesn’t work anymore!

  78. YES SPY IS WINNIN

  79. Sigh I’m tired of grade 5 because GRADE 5 IS MY WORST GRADE EVER!!!!!!

  80. im in 4th grade Grigory! how’s that grade to ya?

  81. wait a sec…
    *ahem* My Important News:
    #1: Strange Moon the Fashion Designer is currently NOT posting any new posts. This might sound strange, but don’t forget there is a “Strange” in her name!
    #2: A lot of you might have already noticed, but a new island is coming out on Poptropica! Its name will be Wild West Island. For Members, it will come out in Feb. Nobody knows for SURE what date of Feb., but that’s the best we know. For non-members, nobody knows for sure either when it will come out.
    #3: In the oh-so-famous Island Smackdown, we are now challenging two popular islands: Time Tangled and Spy! So far, the sneaky Spy Island has the lead! Let us cheer for the Agents living on that famous island! *cheers*

    *ahem* Well peps, this is the latest report for White Sword’s News!

  82. Hello everyone!
    Now for the update on news:
    Many of you poptropicans may have already noticed, but the Island Smackdown is still cheering and congratulating the famous and popular Spy Island.
    #1: In the first place, we have Spy Island in the lead, with 1,134 votes and a percentage of 65%.
    #2: In the second place, we have Time Tangled Island, with a total voter of 617 and a percentage of 35%, but good job Time Tangled! You are still a really great island!
    Besides the Smackdown, we have a sudden rumor of a new island coming out.
    #1: The mysterious island’s name will be Wild West Island. So, speaking of the wild west, many of you will instantly think of cowboys and cowgirls, incluuding ranches, horses, cows and other cattles that ranchers breed. And, you were right. On the Poptropica Map, an island with the words “Sneak Preview” is between Nabooti and Mythology. So, this island isn’t a rumor. This is REAL.
    OK Poptropicans, we still have more! Well, the Poptropica Creators must have thought about how small the Poptropica Store is, so…
    #1: The newest costume available in the store is a fabulous but simple one, called the “Disco King” if your poptropican is a boy. Don’t worry, girls. For you, there will be one called “Disco Queen”.
    #2: The Creators must have done a pretty decent job on coming up with the “Bigfoot Costume”, or whatever it’s called, because I have seem lots of people wearing and showing off with a fake Bigfoot on their heads. That’s the whole costume, really, though, except for a T-shirt and black pants. So, I’m not saying that the T-shirt and the black pants are decent, but mainly because of the awesome, fantastic Bigfoot hat!

    Well, I guess

  83. Hello everyone!
    Now for the update on news:
    Many of you poptropicans may have already noticed, but the Island Smackdown is still cheering and congratulating the famous and popular Spy Island.
    #1: In the first place, we have Spy Island in the lead, with 1,134 votes and a percentage of 65%.
    #2: In the second place, we have Time Tangled Island, with a total voter of 617 and a percentage of 35%, but good job Time Tangled! You are still a really great island!
    Besides the Smackdown, we have a sudden rumor of a new island coming out.
    #1: The mysterious island’s name will be Wild West Island. So, speaking of the wild west, many of you will instantly think of cowboys and cowgirls, incluuding ranches, horses, cows and other cattles that ranchers breed. And, you were right. On the Poptropica Map, an island with the words “Sneak Preview” is between Nabooti and Mythology. So, this island isn’t a rumor. This is REAL.
    OK Poptropicans, we still have more! Well, the Poptropica Creators must have thought about how small the Poptropica Store is, so…
    #1: The newest costume available in the store is a fabulous but simple one, called the “Disco King” if your poptropican is a boy. Don’t worry, girls. For you, there will be one called “Disco Queen”.
    #2: The Creators must have done a pretty decent job on coming up with the “Bigfoot Costume”, or whatever it’s called, because I have seem lots of people wearing and showing off with a fake Bigfoot on their heads. That’s the whole costume, really, though, except for a T-shirt and black pants. So, I’m not saying that the T-shirt and the black pants are decent, but mainly because of the awesome, fantastic Bigfoot hat!

    Well, that’s the latest report for The Weekly Surprise: White Sword the News Reporter. Thanks for listening and reading, have a wonderful, happy and fabulous Chinese New Year on Jan. 3rd!

  84. Phew…
    I hope that that helped everyone new here! 🙂

  85. this is really fun!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! idk why… but… i… do… care… so… haha… to… all… of… you!

  86. nobody… posts… any… more… but… why?

  87. i… almost… made… it… to… 100… comments! :yay: :mrgreen:

  88. all the emoticons: 🙂 🙁 🙂 😆 🙁 :mrgreen: 👿 😡 😥 😀 😉 😛

  89. one more!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! yay!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  90. one excactly more! but nobody will ever read this comment… 🙁

  91. yay i made it yay i made it to the next page!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! oh yeah………. oh yeah………….

  92. Hello everyone!
    Now for the update on news:
    Many of you poptropicans may have already noticed, but the Island Smackdown is still cheering and congratulating the famous and popular Spy Island.
    #1: In the first place, we have Spy Island in the lead, with 1,134 votes and a percentage of 65%.
    #2: In the second place, we have Time Tangled Island, with a total voter of 617 and a percentage of 35%, but good job Time Tangled! You are still a really great island!
    Besides the Smackdown, we have a sudden rumor of a new island coming out.
    #1: The mysterious island’s name will be Wild West Island. So, speaking of the wild west, many of you will instantly think of cowboys and cowgirls, incluuding ranches, horses, cows and other cattles that ranchers breed. And, you were right. On the Poptropica Map, an island with the words “Sneak Preview” is between Nabooti and Mythology. So, this island isn’t a rumor. This is REAL.
    OK Poptropicans, we still have more! Well, the Poptropica Creators must have thought about how small the Poptropica Store is, so…
    #1: The newest costume available in the store is a fabulous but simple one, called the “Disco King” if your poptropican is a boy. Don’t worry, girls. For you, there will be one called “Disco Queen”.
    #2: The Creators must have done a pretty decent job on coming up with the “Bigfoot Costume”, or whatever it’s called, because I have seem lots of people wearing and showing off with a fake Bigfoot on their heads. That’s the whole costume, really, though, except for a T-shirt and black pants. So, I’m not saying that the T-shirt and the black pants are decent, but mainly because of the awesome, fantastic Bigfoot hat!

    Well, that’s the latest report for The Weekly Surprise: White Sword the News Reporter. Thanks for listening and reading, have a wonderful, happy and fabulous Chinese New Year on Jan. 3rd!

    :mrgreen:

  93. All right,
    Let’s hear for our interview with the Weekly Surprise Intersiewer White Star!
    Hello White Star! Anything new for us to hear?
    WS: Why of course.
    #1:OK then! I want to know about the Island Smackdown, first thing of all.
    WS: Well, first thing is that Mythology is winning! With a total vote of 666 votes, Mythology has a percentage of 70%.
    #2: Oh! That’s great. Why is it winning?
    WS: Well, of course, Mythology Island is an awesome one!
    #3: *roll eyes* Oh, well, OK I get it White Sword, but, is something particularly awesome that makes it awesome?
    WS: Well, it allows you to actually meet some of the greatest gods and goddesses in the world.
    #4: Can you name some of them?
    WS: Sure! Athena is my favourite, Artemis, Aphrodite, Apollo, Hestia, Hermes, Ares, and, of course, Zeus, Hades, and Poseidon.
    #5: All right, then! What about the also very popular Counterfeit?
    WS: Oh yes. Counterfeit is one of the most popular islands on Poptropica, our world. With a percentage of 30%, it has a total vote of 288. I know exactly why it is not winning, and almost failing to win. That is because, at least this is what I think, Mythology has a more exciting background and story. Of course, thieves are all around us. But, really, no poptropican can ever see a god or goddess that often.
    #6: All right then! Thank you very much, Star.

    Well, this concludes our interview with the Weekly Surprise! Thank you for listening and reading, and happy Chinese New Year today! The people in China are already celebrating today! 新年快乐! (Happy New Year!)

  94. i’m on! school canceled! snow day! yay for me! haha! yeah! oh yeah! un huh! oh yeah! oh yay!

  95. Hello everyone. Today is Feb. 13th, 2011. Welcome to the Weekly Surprise: News Report. Today we will have a report with News Reporter White Star!
    Today’s subject will be: El Mustachio Grande

    #1: Hello White Star.
    WS: Hello White Sword. What would you like to ask about Grande?
    #2: Well, I do have something to ask. First of all, who is El Mustachio Grande?
    WS: That’s an interesting question. Grande is the main villain of the suddenly-popped up Wild West Island. In the paragraph describing Wild West Island, it said that a dark shadow was lurking around on Wild West. That dark “shadow” is El Mustachio Grande.
    #3: That’s some nice informations, Star. Do you know what he looks like?
    WS: Well, the Poptropica Creators printed a very blurry picture of Grande, so nobody knows for sure what he’ll look like. The Weekly Surprise predict that he has a big mustache, and a some how “evil” pair of eyes.
    #4: Oh! Well, what do you think his proffesion is?
    WS: According to our prediction, Grande is most likely to be a cowboy or a rancher. Except, no matter what he is, we know for sure that he will be evil.
    #5: Well that’s some shuddering news. My last and most important question is, do you think Grande will become a popular villain, like, for example, the popular Dr. Hare on 24 Carrots Island, Black Widow on Counterfeit Island, Betty Jetty, or Zeus?
    WS: We must know this: it is only after an island comes out that we know for sure what it will be like. Therefore I am sorry to say that I don’t know the answer.
    #6: Thank you very much for the fantastic info, Star and have a good day. Happy Valentines Day!
    WS: Wish you a happy Valentine too!

    OK well this concludes our report with Star.

  96. YAY spy island won i LOVE spy island SPY ISLAND IS extra super supreme awesome

  97. 🙂 🙁 🙂 😆 🙁 :mrgreen: 👿 😡 😥 😀 😉 😛

  98. 😆