Home | Poptropica | Island Smackdown – Early Poptropica vs. Shark Tooth Island

Island Smackdown – Early Poptropica vs. Shark Tooth Island

Hey Poptropica fans, ever wonder which is the best Poptropica Island ever? What better way than to put it to a vote. Starting this week, we’re going to hold a tournament where we put two islands up head to head and then you get to vote on which island is best. The winner advances to the next round and the loser is cast aside.

In the first round, we’ll put two old favorites up against each other: Early Poptropica Island and Shark Tooth Island. These were the first two islands released in Poptropica and both are very easy to complete. If you follow the walkthroughs for each, you can finish them each in under ten minutes! Read about each of the islands below and then cast your vote at the bottom on which you think is the better of the two!

Early Poptropica

Completing Early Poptropica Walkthrough

Early Poptropica is the first island that most Poptropica players take on in the game. In this quest, your job is to help the settlers of Early Poptropica recover three items that have been stolen. Your adventures will take you deep underground and high up in the clouds as you search to find their missing pig, bucket and flag. In Early Poptropica, you’ll try to avoid spiders, get past a giant, and even fly around with your own jet pack.

Shark Tooth

In Shark Tooth Island, you’ll have to get past the giant shark in Booga Bay and rescue Professor Hammerhead and a small boy who have been trapped on an island off-shore. You’ll need to get the help of the local medicine man and uncover some of the ancient mysteries of the island deep underground while you try to get the ingredients you’ll need for the medicine man’s potion. Shark Tooth Island is quick and easy to finish, and features an entire museum about sharks. It’s also the home of the famous Shark Boy!

Let’s Vote

So which of these two islands do you like best? Which one should advance to the next round in the Poptropica Island Smackdown? Vote for your favorite below and check back in a few days to vote on the next set of contenders!

Which Island is Better?

  • Shark Tooth (69%, 1,242 Votes)
  • Early Poptropica (31%, 565 Votes)

Total Voters: 1,796

Loading ... Loading ...

About Fierce Moon

Fierce Moon is the chief blogger here at PoptropicaSecrets.com and loves to play Poptropica along with a bunch of other online games.

135 comments

  1. GO SHARK TOOTH!!!!

  2. here is the link to my blog, and please add it to your favorites: http://funstuffandawesomeness.blogspot.com/

  3. WHY?!?!?!?!? DOES EARLY POPTROPICA HAVE TO LOSE?!?!?!!??!!?!?!?!

  4. A lot of votes so far, everyone! I’ll keep the poll open for a few days so that everyone gets a chance to vote. Then we’ll go to round two: 24 Carrot vs. Time Tangled.

  5. GO SHARK TOOTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  6. cool, i like time tangled lol

  7. more votes come every second

  8. me too

  9. PoptropicaSecrets. So you are the one in charge of this blog. Cool. So if you know stuff about Poptropica and stuff could you find out when Crydit Island come out we have waited to long. And one more thing 24carrots vs time tangled island. TIME TANGLED IS GONNA WIN BY A LONG SHOT. TIME TANGLED RULES!!!!!

  10. and shark tooth is cool but what about Early Poptropica it has a jetpack and ogre or giant or something a giant spider in the sewer without early poptropica we might not have had Counterfiet Island. But Shark Tooth is a little cooler since its a troical island with ruins and a giant shark. So I vote for Shark Tooth.

  11. by the way if you put astroknights, skullduggery, or steamworks island agaisat each other it would be hard to know which won would because they are all so AWSOME

  12. Shark Tooth vs. Early Poptropica!Hmmmmmmmmmm………………

  13. I wand to be very rich on poptropica

  14. GO SHARK TOOTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  15. hi im xylon8super

    i want new islands called ice land gives you 300 credits,fire land gives you 300 too and

    the most 1 is temple power island gives you 10000 credits πŸ™‚

    wich 1 u like tell me and i give you some medals but who gives me his acc ok bye:) hope u like this message

  16. or add me in msn

    email:xylon-mizzi@hotmail.com

    ^_^ πŸ™‚

  17. Poptrabica Fans speak

  18. GO SHARK TOOTH!!!!!! πŸ˜€ i love poptropica

  19. GO EVERY ISLAND!!!! πŸ˜€ GO SHARK TOOTH AND EARLY POPTROPICA!!!!!!!!!!! πŸ˜€

  20. I voted for Early Poptropica cuz’ it’s AWESOME!!!

  21. go shark tooth πŸ˜‰

  22. wait and Early poptropica:`(

  23. HEYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!DAILY POP IS NOW AVAILABLE!!!!!!!THE SCREEN HAS CHANGED TOO WHEN YOU PLAY!!!!IT IS IN THE TOP RIGHT CORNER OF YOUR SCREEN NEXT TO THE COSTUMIZER BUTTON!

  24. whats the point of haveing a smacdown if everybody loves diffrent islands:(
    im not saing that ihate poptropica witch is btw sooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooASWOME(bytheway)

  25. oh my b! im not tring 2 start afan wor:D

  26. SHARK TOOTH ISLAND ROCKS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  27. c there doing all of this for publisaty

  28. that means there tring 2 iant got nothing!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  29. jeff kenny is the creator of poptropica!

  30. ACTUALLY MAYBE ASTRO KNIGHTS AND SKULLDUGERYISLAND WOULD BE A BETTER COMPITITION CAUSE IN ASTRO KNIGHTS YOU GET TO BUILD YOUR OWN SPACE SHIP AND DISTROY ALIENS HOW COOL IS THAT, IN SCULLDUGERY YOU GET TO KEEP YOUR OWN SHIP AND SINK OTHERS AND HAVE TREASURE. YEAH STEAMWORKS IS KIND OF COOL BECAUSE YOU HAVE A GIGANTIC ROBOT BUT ITS SLOW!THE CRAB ROBOT IS RRREEAAALLY COOL THOUGHT. EARLY POPTROPICA IS TO EASY , I BEAT IN UNDER A MINUTE,WHATS THE POINT IN YOUSING THE JET PACK IF YOU CANT YOUSE IT ANY WHERE ELS. EARLY POPTROPICA SUCKS SHARK TOOTH ISLAND RULES AND POPTROPICA IS THE BEST GAME IN THE WHOLE IN TIRE WORLD!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  31. Early Poptropica rocks, i voted for it!

  32. why r uargeeing with me im crazy yyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy
    so dont agreee with meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee
    plese dont im a5 greaderplesedont.

  33. wnaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa now im sad beacuse people r agreeng with meeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee

  34. poptropica is so different with daily pop!

  35. dont argeee with me i like alot of the islands but still im crazzzzzzzyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

  36. hey everbody im forming aband called gray star.

  37. PLEASE GO TO MY POPTROPICA ROOM ITS ATA19 CRYSTEL CAVERN I REALLY WANT TO CHAT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  38. THERES GOING TO BE FIRE WORKS SNOWING AND YOU GET TO SEE MY REALLY AWSOUME COSTOUME

  39. TIME TANGELED ISLAND,SPY AND SUPER POWER ISLAND ARE MY FAVORITE ISLANDS YET.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  40. HELLO? IS ANY BODY THERE?

  41. NOT SNOWING IMEAN SNOW. ITS GOING TO BE SNOWING THERE.

  42. please answer

  43. GO SHAAAAARK TOOOOOTH!!!!

  44. SHAAAAAAAAARK TOOOOOOOTH!

  45. i love jeff kinneys diary of a wimpy kid and when i found out that he made poptropica i was so HAPPY!!!!!!!!! go jeff kinney! I LOVE YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! im your 1# fan!

  46. I KNEW SHARK TOOTH ISLAND WAS GOING O WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  47. When does a new island comes?

  48. Skullduggery or Counterfeit

  49. Go Shark Tooth! What’s up with the bad grammar?

  50. Logan Watason (Big Fan)

    SHARK TOOTH!!!!!

  51. DEFINETLY Early poptropica it was the FIRST island before shark tooth AND you get a secret coustume, the arcade, AND a jetpack!

  52. GO SHARK TOOTH GO!!!!!!!! I HOPE SHARK TOOTH WINS!!!!!!

  53. DING DING DING!!!!! ( Thats the sound for the westlers to start the battle ) SHARK TOOTH JUST SMACKED EARLY POPTROPICA ON THE GROUND!!!!! But wait, EARLY POPTROPICA SMACKS OFF SHARK TOOTH’S SMILE!!!!!!SHARK TOOTH SMACKED EARLY POPTROPICA’S SMILE OFF TOO!!!!! WHO WILL WIN????? TAKE A VOTE!!!!! REMEMBER,ONE WILL STAND AND ONE WILL FALL!!!!!!
    From your imanginable person,
    The Little Poptropican Girl That Could

  54. Go Poptropica!! Super Thunder does have great style. Its true she does.

  55. Shark Tooth Island Won!

  56. hi im bj and my poptropica name is chao_monster

  57. the new dairy of a wimpy kid stinks. it not as good as the rest.

  58. princeess middle east

    I don’t like either of them.
    Why can’t they put counterfeit Island up there?
    πŸ™
    πŸ™
    πŸ™
    πŸ™
    πŸ™

  59. princeess middle east

    yes it is!
    It’s the best I will maybe get 1 for Christmas.
    JEFF KINNEY RULES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  60. i hope eraliy poptropica wins!!!!!!!!!!!

  61. HI IM GABBY VELLA I TALK SPANISH AND I KONW ALOT OF POPTROPICA CHEATS AND TIPS SOO COMMENT BACK SO YOU CAN KNOW

  62. I HAVE BEAT ALL OF POPTROPICA!!
    IM GONNA BEAT FOUR MORE AND GIVE IT AWAY!! IF U WANT ONE OF THEM ILL GIVE IT TO.. IM 14

  63. hey kristiw1 you spelled early wrong and shark tooth will win

  64. which will win spy island or super power island.I say super power island

  65. i also say superpower island is cool. yyyeeeeeeaaaaahhhh!!!!! it rules

  66. hey fearless tiger I say spy island cause u get a chameleon suit!!!

  67. SHARK TOOTH ISLAND!

  68. Indiana Jones theme! bum bum bum bummm bum bum bummm bum bum bumbumm bum bah bumbumbum bum bah bum bummmm bum bah bummm bah bug bum bum bah bah bug bum buh baaaa

  69. Okay here are the rates when I saw them…

    (69% 625 Votes) For shark tooth!

    (31% 284 Votes) For early poptropica…
    SHARK TOOTH WINS!! Good thing I voted for shark tooth πŸ˜€ OMG!! OMG!! OMG!! AaAAAAAH! Bwwaaaahahahahahah GOOOOO… SHARK TOOTH!

  70. go sharktooth!!!!:D

  71. EARLY POPTROPICA RULES!
    BOO SHARK TOOTH!

  72. EARLY POPTROPICA RULES!
    BOO SHARK TOOTH!

    GO EARLY POPTROPICA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  73. πŸ™

  74. you spelt early wrong and shark tooth won hahaha

  75. SHARK TOOTH ALL THE WAY!

  76. they are both awsome!!! πŸ˜€

  77. GIVE ME AN S! GIVE ME AN T!
    GIVE ME AN H! GIVE ME AN O!
    GIVE ME AN A! GIVE ME AN O!
    GIVE ME AN R! GIVE ME AN T!
    GIVE ME AN K! GIVE ME AN H!

    WHAT DOES IT SPELL?! SHARK TOOTH!!!

  78. I LOVE SHARK TOOTH BECAUSE ITS MUCH MORE LONGER AND EARLY POPTROPICA IS JUST LIKE 10 MINS TO BEAT

  79. when does cryptids island come out for members?

  80. YEH,GO SHARK TOOTH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  81. WAIT, REALLY, JEFF KINNEY IS THE CREATER.AWSOUME,YOU ROCK JEFF KINNEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  82. I’m with shy beetle, they r both cool. but what if more people who have not voted start voting
    4 early poptropica????!!! so u can’t tell who will really win.

  83. jeff kinny is the man who writes diary of a wimpykid

  84. Ok, I’m all for the whole Tropical/Shark thing, but please, finishing Sharktooth Island took me five minutes of pure BOREDOM! As for Early Poptropica, it was never one of my favorites, but at least it wasn’t extremely EASY, and it made me THINK.

  85. The smackdown will be on November 29 at 459 CT Transit driver’s house in Early Poptropica Island.

  86. Hey its Mad, & if u tried it plz comment or comment if u think its cool. So if u press ctrl & shift with 1,2,or3, ur character will do a action even out of a chat room! If u press ctrl shift + 3 and ctrl shift 4 or 3, it will look like u’ve been in the sun too long. I wish there was sunblock in the store,people! πŸ˜€

  87. lolmynameizcheerfuldolphin

    Cool! How do u do the sunblock thingy? I tried it so many times!

  88. none is good okay …………………………………just kitten………………………………………………………………………………..

  89. YO PEOPLE! SHARK TOOTH WILL WIN!!!!!!!!!!!!

  90. SHARK TOOTH RULES!!!! EARLY POPTROPICA STINKS!!!! YAY SHARK TOOTH!!!!!! BOO EARLY POPTROPICA!!!!

  91. Shark tooth is better.

  92. I actually like Early Poptropica better. It’s easy and it has a lot of fun stuff you can do on it.

  93. poptropica go u r the man

  94. Go EARLY POPTROPICA!
    Sorry. I love that island much more.

  95. I love typing in bold.
    Bold.
    Bold.
    Bold.


  96. Give me an E! give me an A! Give me a R! Give me a L! Give me a Y! give me a P-O-P-T-R-O-P-I-C-A! put it all together and what does it spell! Early Poptropica!
    shark Tooth is lame!
    And so is it’s name!
    Early Poptropica is better!
    And it is all the same!
    Go!
    Early poptropica!
    no offense to those who like Shark Tooth. Professor Pendelum is on that island.

  97. I LOVE BOTH ISLANDS BUT EARLY POPTROPICA IS MY FAVORITE OUT OF BOTH.

  98. i really think there both sucky so i pick shark tooth

  99. both of the islands are boring….
    so i just chose early poptropica…

  100. shark tooth is good because you feed the shark a sleeping posion but early poptropica is good because you meet a geant and see a golden egg so i like them both i give them both a 100 persant!!!!

  101. so yea both good

  102. but i agree with bo bo they are kinda boring to.

  103. go shark tooth !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1000 prssent im going for you

  104. go shark tooth

  105. i love early poptropica

  106. GO SHARK TOOTH! BOO EARLY POPTROPICA!

  107. early poptropica is so boring and lame in shark tooth you get to fire coconuts and make a potion

  108. i choose early poptropica

  109. both are good im not voteing but early poptropica is better

  110. i like early poptropica because you get a jet pack!!! and you can flu around

  111. boo boo shark tooth send it back to baby school if they cry let them die boo boo shark tooth

  112. Everyone’s Wrong!!!
    Counterfeit’s the best!!!

    Early Pop is lame!
    Shark tooth lost it’s game!

  113. I’ve finished Early Poptropica,but I like Shark Tooth better…..

  114. no,no,no. EVERY island is THE BEST.

  115. I don’t know who to vote for ;(

  116. Friendly Ghost

    *I Love Early Pop Better!*
    *No offense to Shark Tooth likers.*
    *I Hate Booga!*

  117. Friendly Ghost

    HOW DO YOU WRITE IN BOLD?

  118. Shark tooth

  119. h e r e is a list of islands i love sharktooth,spy,big nate,counterfeit,realitytv,skullduggery,cryptids,wimpy wonderland ,mystery train,game show

  120. SHARK TOOTH SHARK TOOTH

  121. I like both of the island so I didn’t vote.

  122. ξŒ‘ξ„“ξ€±ξŒŽξ„»ξ‚ξ€ξξ„°ξ‚ξ„ ξŒ»ξƒξŒΌξŒ½ξŒΊξŒΎξ…ξ†ξ†ξ‹ξŠξ‰ξΏξˆͺξ‰ξˆŸξˆžξˆξˆ·ξˆ₯ξˆ²ξˆ³ξˆ»ξˆΊξˆ΅ξˆΈξˆΉξˆ·ξˆΆξ”ΆξŽξ”›ξ™

  123. They are both so easy i have beat them 10xs!